Machismo,
which generally refers to strong or aggressive masculine pride, holds a great
presence in Tlamacazapa, which has oppressed women into anonymity. Although the
concept may considered to be outdate in the United States, it remains to be a
common belief in Tlamacazapa that the men are the head of the household, which
leaves without power and responsible for all household chores. Disagreement or
disobedience frequently results in spousal abuse, which is escalated by the
high occurrence of alcoholism in the town. Available public education only runs
until middle school, which is taught through television programming which is
inconsistent due to an occasional lack of signal. A common way to earn a living
in Tlamacazapa is by weaving ornate baskets out of palm leaves. The palm dye is
another toxin that can affect ones health, and 3 days of work may produce one
basket worth as little as $15 USD. After travel costs and other expenses, the
income is hardly enough to buy beans and rice for a family, let alone send
their children to study.
ATZIN
is a nonprofit organization started in 1997, working more specifically with the
women of Tlamacazapa to teach them self-sufficiency, strengthening the self,
and rebuilding the community. ATZIN’s services include but aren’t limited to:
family planning, health/dental care, education of youth and adults, midwifery,
environmental and nutritional courses, and providing of food. We were fortunate enough to meet the
scholarship students, educators, and organizers of ATZIN, who were some of the
most brave and inspirational individuals I’ve ever met in my life. We were
given tours throughout the town, carried water down the steep streets, and
shared intimate moments with native families.
Although the trip was incredibly impactful,
I think we all have to recognize that we only experienced one day in
Tlamacazapa, not enough time to see the pain and struggle behind the shining
smiles of the Tlamacazapans. I believe that seeing the difference between
educating yourself on the realities of others or simply a good opportunity for
a new Facebook photo album is of extreme importance.
Can you think of examples where poverty has
been exploited or glamorized?
-- Galina Bruckner
-- Galina Bruckner

Great post, Galina!
ReplyDeleteIn response to your question, I have heard of many nexamples of where poverty has been glamorized or exploited. Shortly after the film Slumdog Millionaire was released, some critics objected to the film's portrayal of poverty in India. These concerns were heightened after the growth of "Slum Tourism" occurred. These tours offer travelers the opportunity to view some of the largest "shanty towns" in India.
Follow the link to hear the full discussion on the controversies surrounding Slumdog Millionaire's "poverty porn".
Link: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=101487893
-Devon Arndt
Wonderful post Galina!
ReplyDeleteAlso in response to your question I have also heard of many examples of where poverty has been glamorized or exploited. The Filipinos are a group of people who have been in poverty and still remain in poverty. It seems as if there has been glamorization of the poor among the people. This glamorization not only gives the wrong idea about the people, but it also seems like it's a way to keep them poor.
In response to this post I have been to other pueblos in México were poverty is very common, and these pueblos are often indigenous. Just like Native Americans here in the United States alcoholism and spousal abuse are large problems faced by both populations. I believe that the problem in México is possibly worse, because many women think this violence and way of life is ok. Also, here in the united states children of almost any background are able to become educated. I was happy to see there is such a program like ATZIN which is helping the women of indigenous women of México become stronger I hope to see more of these come into being.
ReplyDelete